[islandlabs] Mailing list settings
Island Labs main mailing list
Mon Dec 15 12:17:31 EST 2008
I'm not opposed to anonymity, but it's kinda normal to have a "handle" or signature associated w/ each person.
If someone chose to identify themselves as "the green goblin" and signed that way consistently, I'd be fine w/ it, even if they chose not to identify themselves that way in person, or admit to their online persona.
On the other hand, it's just plain annoying to find a random comment somewhere, and not know who it's coming from, and what "thread", or chain of thought it belongs to.
Being that the annoyed person is not the one forgetting to identify themselves, and not the one capable of shouldering the "burden" of remembering to identify themselves, it's a solution that's bound to fail.
In theory, the list could attract trolls, and we (as list users) would be unable to filter them out.
I believe that a "munged" address would be the best technical solution to the social problem.
From: list-bounces at islandlabs.org on behalf of Island Labs main mailing list
Sent: Mon 12/15/2008 11:59 AM
To: Island Labs main mailing list
Subject: Re: [islandlabs] Mailing list settings
Putting the burden on the person seems like not a bad solution too an
annoyance for the average person, and I'm for that.
On the other hand, this is an interesting conversation. I think that
internet anonymity is important, and something that is endangered.
Something that perhaps a technological group should take a stand for.
Tech people aren't the only ones upset about this, internet anonymity
is also important for the continued assurance of a free press:
purposely anonymous (....unless you are the admin of this list and you
feel like parsing logs, or you're the government and are breaking the
On Mon, Dec 15, 2008 at 11:21 AM, Island Labs main mailing list
<list at islandlabs.org> wrote:
> Is there an option to "munge" the e-mail address, but still include it
> in the body of the e-mail.
> That way addresses wouldn't be harvested for SPAM, but we'd still know
> who we were talking to.
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: list-bounces at islandlabs.org
>> [mailto:list-bounces at islandlabs.org] On Behalf Of Island Labs
>> main mailing list
>> Sent: Sunday, December 14, 2008 9:17 AM
>> To: list at islandlabs.org
>> Subject: [islandlabs] Mailing list settings
>> "Hide the sender of a message, replacing it with the list
>> address (Removes From, Sender and Reply-To fields)"
>> Yes or no.
>> I'm not sure what people want, some people say they need to
>> know who sent an email and others say everyone should just
>> sign their messages.
>> The list is *not* broken, its just configured to hide the sender.
>> I can easily disable that, but I'm not sure what you all want.
>> Post your opinion on the matter (and sign the email please).
>> Tony Biondo
>> tonyb [at] tonybox.net
>> List mailing list
>> List at islandlabs.org
> List mailing list
> List at islandlabs.org
List mailing list
List at islandlabs.org
More information about the List